Rise of anti-Semitism a concern for area Jews, Christians

Rabbi Debbie Stiel has led Topeka’s Temple Beth Sholom for 13 years. The Oct. 27 shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh has left temple leaders grappling with being welcoming to guests but also providing a sense of security for 100 families. LEAVEN PHOTO BY MARC ANDERSON

by Marc and Julie Anderson

TOPEKA — Hanukkah, or the Jewish Festival of Lights, commemorates the rededication of the Temple by the Maccabees after their victory over the Seleucid Empire. 

But as Jews throughout the United States celebrate the festival, which runs from Dec. 2-10 this year, people of all faiths are also concerned about the dramatic rise of anti-Semitism in recent months.

According to the Encyclopedia Brittanica, the term was coined in 1879 by Wilhelm Marr to designate the anti- Jewish campaigns in central Europe. 

And the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), an international organization founded in 1913 to “stop the defamation of the Jewish people and to secure justice and fair treatment to all,” has been tracking incidents since 1979. Anti- Semitism can take the form of harassment, vandalism and assault.

According to ADL data, the number of anti-Semitic acts from 2016 to 2017 increased 57 percent, the largest single- year increase on record. 

And the statistics represent only reported incidents. 

Rabbi Debbie Stiel has led Topeka’s Temple Beth Sholom for 13 years. In that time, she said, she recalls only one act of vandalism on temple property. 

Still, the Oct. 27 shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh that resulted in the deaths of 11 has left temple leaders grappling with being welcoming to guests but also providing a sense of security for 100 families.

Dr. Richard Crane, a professor of European history at Benedictine College in Atchison, said American society has seen its share of religious discrimination. 

Both the professor and the rabbi feel as if the overall climate in American society today is partially to blame.

“There’s an unwillingness to value difference,” Crane said, “and to see our fellow people as brothers and sisters. It’s very troubling.”

Rabbi Stiel agreed. 

And today’s technology, she said, particularly social media, has contributed to an increase in hate speech.

On the whole, though, Crane said America is extremely tolerant, and that’s why Americans become outraged at acts of violence.

“We’re virtually all mourning and are horrified together,” he said of the shooting in Pittsburgh.

Rabbi Stiel agreed.

“I think somebody said Jews were murdered, but all Americans were assaulted,” she said, “and I think that’s really how Americans felt.

“We like to think of our sanctuaries as very safe spaces, and it feels particularly heinous for a sanctuary to be a target of a shooting.”

Crane said such acts of hatred are troubling, but he sees hope, too.

“I’d like to think that acts of hatred are not indicative of a larger trend in our country, but are examples of extremes,” he said. “[However,] we live in a country where these things are happening. The idea that Jewish people in their schools and synagogues have to have armed guards and extremely heightened security is very, very disheartening.

“But at the same time, I think they have the sympathy, support and outrage of the American people and our government.”

Support, the rabbi noted, is something her congregation has felt.

In the aftermath of the Pittsburgh shooting, leaders of the American Jewish Committee encouraged Jews to show up on the next Sabbath in large numbers to show solidarity.

“We decided to combine it with an opportunity for the community to come here, too,” said Rabbi Stiel, “both to show their support for the Jewish community and to gain some comfort for themselves.

“Typically, we get 35 to 40 people on a Friday night for Sabbath service, and we had over 300 people there that night.

“I think Jews wanted to be here on that day, but it was an incredible outpouring of support from the community.”

The professor and the rabbi noted such events can help build bridges. 

“Familiarity with Jews as persons actually inhibits anti-Semitism,” Crane said. 

The same can be said for prejudices of any kind, he continued. Familiarity erodes prejudices as people get to know one another as human beings.

Connections, Rabbi Stiel said, can be particularly powerful when made among religious leaders.

“I do think that when the religious leaders of the different faiths get to know each other personally, that connection ends up filtering down,” she said. 

“They build friendships,” she added, “and I think that that can be very powerful, very instructive.”

Judy Ulitchny, a member of St. Michael the Archangel Parish in Leawood, and Larry and Patty Pressman, members of Temple Beth Shalom, agreed. 

As leader of a faith club in which women of the Muslim, Jewish and Catholic faiths come together, Ulitchny said she has learned much and tries to educate others.

“There’s so much ignorance of the other faiths,” she said.

And ignorance can translate into fear and prejudice.

Growing up in Topeka, Larry Pressman played on church-sponsored softball and basketball teams as the only Jewish member. As a result, he developed friendships that made him appreciate the commonalities of other faiths as well as their differences.

“We’re never going to eliminate this [hatred] as long as we don’t understand each other,” Patty Pressman said.

Both the professor and the rabbi pointed to “Nostra Aetate,” a document which came out of the Second Vatican Council, as being a watershed moment.

“I really appreciate the Catholic Church and what it’s done with Vatican II to say you can’t hold all Jews responsible for deicide,” said Rabbi Stiel. “The Jews are still God’s special people as well.

“I think that has helped to dial back some of the rhetoric and to increase connections between the Jewish and Catholic communities.”

Now, she said, the two communities can appreciate each other.

Father Joseph Arsenault, SSA, the archdiocesan officer for ecumenical and interreligious affairs, agreed.

“When we stand together in solidarity with people from the Jewish community, we stand with our brothers and our sisters,” he said. “We are all children of the one God. It was to the Jewish people that he first revealed himself. 

“Many of our traditions and ways have their roots in the Jewish faith. We have a common heritage and, in coming together to support one another and getting to know one another strengthens us and makes us better.”

About the author

Marc & Julie Anderson

Freelancers Marc and Julie Anderson are long-time contributors to the Leaven. Married in 1996, for several years the high school sweethearts edited The Crown, the former newspaper of Christ the King Parish in Topeka which Julie has attended since its founding in 1977. In 2000, the Leaven offered the couple their first assignment. Since then, the Andersons’ work has also been featured in a variety of other Catholic and prolife media outlets. The couple has received numerous journalism awards from the Knights of Columbus, National Right to Life and the Catholic Press Association including three for their work on “Think It’s Not Happening Near You? Think Again,” a piece about human trafficking. A lifelong Catholic, Julie graduated from Most Pure Heart of Mary Grade School and Hayden Catholic High School in Topeka. Marc was received into the Catholic Church in 1993 at St. Paul Parish – Newman Center at Wichita State University. The two hold degrees from Washburn University in Topeka. Their only son, William James, was stillborn in 1997.

Leave a Comment